Where an old water heater can go depends on where you live and who is removing it, and the official pages we read answer part of that, not all of it. The City of Lancaster names water heaters among its white goods, collected through a monthly program with a $15 tag bought from the Treasury Office. The Lancaster County Solid Waste Management Authority lists appliances and white goods among the items accepted at its sites, with published fees, but its rate page does not name water heaters. Townships and boroughs outside the City run their own programs that we did not confirm. This page sets out what is published, what is not, and how to avoid being surprised on removal day.
Handle with care. A water heater is heavy, and one that has just been shut down can hold hot water. State Water Heaters’ manual says its gas tankless unit is heavy and to use at least two people to lift it. Turn off power or gas and let the water cool before anyone drains or moves a unit, and do not drain a hot tank. If you smell gas, leave the building and see our shut-off guide.
If You Live In The City Of Lancaster
The City of Lancaster says water heaters are white goods that will not be collected with weekly trash, and offers a monthly collection program for them. Its trash and recycling page lists white goods as large appliances including refrigerators, freezers, air conditioners, dehumidifiers, water coolers, clothes washers and dryers, water heaters and microwaves. It says the monthly program uses a $15 tag purchased from the Treasury Office at 39 West Chestnut Street, and gives the reason that the program ensures refrigerant gases are recovered in compliance with federal air quality regulations.
The page points to a calendar of collection dates, which we could not read as text, so check the page itself for the date and for any set-out rules. The page lists a Solid Waste Hotline at (717) 291-4744 in its oversized items paragraph; it does not say whether that line answers white goods questions, so ask when you call. This applies to City collection; it does not describe what happens in neighboring townships.
County Drop-Off: The Lancaster County Solid Waste Management Authority
The county authority lists appliances and white goods as accepted items at its sites, but the rate page we read does not name water heaters, so confirm by phone first. The table records what its pages say, as read on October 25, 2026. None of these figures is confirmed for a water heater. The official way to confirm is to call the Authority at (717) 397-9968, the number its page lists, and ask whether a water heater is accepted and at which fee.
| Item | What the page says |
|---|---|
| Accepted items, household trash category | Household trash, furniture, white goods (refrigerators and air conditioning units), appliances, and liquid and electronic household hazardous items. Water heaters are not named. |
| Fee, household trash | $40 minimum fee per visit up to 680 pounds at the Transfer Station Complex, or up to 800 pounds at the other sites. |
| Fee, single item | $15 each for any single item under 200 pounds; accepted items include furniture, appliances, mattresses and white goods. |
| Payment | Credit or debit cards only; no cash or checks. |
| Transfer Station Complex | 1299 Harrisburg Pike, Lancaster. Weekdays 6AM to 4PM, Saturday 7AM to 11AM. Lancaster County waste only. Telephone (717) 397-9968. |
| Household hazardous waste facility | Free for county residents. It says it does not accept from businesses, and its accepted-items list does not name water heaters. |
The rate page also contains unfinished placeholder wording, and fees and hours may have changed since we read it, so confirm the fee, the hours and whether a water heater is accepted. Whether a tank must be drained, how it should be set down or whether another category applies is not stated on the pages we read, so ask.
Replacing a water heater and wondering who takes the old one? Call (717) 500-8528 and ask before the day.
If You Live Outside The City
Townships and boroughs set their own rules, and we have not confirmed them. We attempted to read Lancaster Township’s disposal page and it returned an access error to us, so we state nothing about it or about any other municipality. Your municipal office or trash hauler is the source: ask whether water heaters are collected curbside, by tag or appointment, or not at all, and what preparation they expect. We found no county-wide rule that overrides them.
Scrap metal buyers are another route in principle, because a water heater is mostly metal, but we did not verify any Lancaster-area buyer’s current policy, hours or price, so we name none and state no scrap value. The pages we read do not say whether a tank must be drained or stripped of fittings first, so ask the buyer or the facility.
Handling And Preparation: What The Manuals Support
The manufacturer documents support shutting the unit down and draining it as the manual directs, and nothing more specific about disposal. The State electric manual’s draining steps start with turning off the electric power, closing the cold water inlet, opening a hot faucet, connecting a hose to the drain valve and ending it at an adequate drain or outdoors; our flushing guide compares those steps with Rheem and Bradford White. A unit that has been flooded, burned or damaged is a separate situation; see flood damage. If there is no drain for the water, see no floor drain. Gas and electrical connections should be disconnected by a qualified person; we found no source that supports a do-it-yourself disconnect, so we describe none.
Homeowner Disposal Versus An Installer’s Removal
A county or City program for homeowners is a different thing from a contractor removing your old unit, and the two should not be confused. The Authority’s household hazardous waste facility says it does not accept from businesses, and the Authority publishes commercial rates separately, which we did not read. Per the business owner, removal of the old unit by this business is included at no separate charge. That is the owner’s statement and is not independently verified, and it does not mean you have to use this business to remove the old unit: the City and county routes above exist for homeowners. If you are comparing quotes, the worksheet in our installation quote guide has an Old unit row for exactly this question: ask whether removal and disposal are included, in writing.
Questions To Settle Before Removal Day
- Who is taking the old unit, you or the installer, and where does it go?
- Which program covers your address, City collection, a county site or your hauler?
- What does that program expect of the unit: drained, disconnected, tagged, set at a certain spot?
- What does it cost and how is it paid? The City and the Authority publish different figures; others may differ.
- Is the date workable? The City’s program runs on set collection dates.
For the replacement itself, see water heater installation in Lancaster, PA and, if you are unsure of the old unit’s age, how to find it.
Sources Used
City of Lancaster, Trash & Recycling page (cityoflancasterpa.gov); Lancaster County Solid Waste Management Authority, Residential Disposal Rates, Recycling and Household Hazardous Waste Facility pages (lcswma.org); State Water Heaters residential electric and gas tankless manuals. Lancaster Township’s page returned an access error and was not used. Fees and hours are as published on October 25, 2026 and may change. Details and excerpts are in our claims registry.
Replacing A Water Heater And Need The Old One Handled?
Service requests and emergency service are available 24/7 across Lancaster City and Lancaster County.
Call For Emergency ServiceWater Heater Disposal FAQ
How do I get rid of an old water heater in Lancaster, PA?
It depends on your address. The City of Lancaster lists water heaters as white goods collected through a monthly program with a $15 tag from the Treasury Office; the county authority lists appliances and white goods at its sites; other municipalities set their own rules. Confirm with the program that covers you.
Will the county take a water heater?
The authority’s rate page lists appliances and white goods as accepted items, but it does not name water heaters. Call (717) 397-9968 to confirm that a water heater is accepted, what the fee is and whether the tank must be drained.
How much does it cost to dispose of a water heater in Lancaster County?
The published figures are $15 for the City tag and, at the county authority, $15 each for a single item under 200 pounds or a $40 minimum fee per visit for household trash. We could not confirm which of the county figures applies to a water heater, and fees may have changed, so treat all of them as unconfirmed for a water heater. Call the Authority at (717) 397-9968 to confirm before you go.
Does the installer take away the old water heater?
That is a question for each installer, in writing. Removal of the old unit by this business is included at no separate charge, per the owner. The old-unit row in our quote worksheet covers the question for any installer.
Can I sell an old water heater for scrap?
Scrap buyers exist in principle, but we verified no Lancaster-area buyer’s policy or price. Call a buyer before you move the unit, and ask what preparation they expect.
Who handles old water heater removal near me in Lancaster County?
Lancaster Water Heater Pros services water heaters across Lancaster City and Lancaster County. Call (717) 500-8528 to ask about your replacement, and ask about removal in writing. Service requests are accepted 24/7.